David Harris
- David Harris
Understanding the Difference Between PIR and PUR Cold Room Panels
When it comes to constructing a cold room, selecting the right insulation material is crucial. The thermal efficiency, fire resistance, and overall durability of the insulation panels determine the energy efficiency, safety, and longevity of the cold room. Two commonly used materials for insulation panels are PIR (Polyisocyanurate) and PUR (Polyurethane). While they might seem similar at first glance, there are significant differences between PIR and PUR cold room panels that can affect their performance and suitability for different applications. This article explores these differences in detail.
1. Chemical Composition
PIR (Polyisocyanurate): PIR is a thermoset plastic, produced by a chemical reaction between isocyanates and polyols, with an excess of isocyanates. This reaction forms strong chemical bonds, creating a rigid foam with a closed-cell structure. The presence of extra isocyanates makes PIR more chemically stable and resistant to high temperatures.
PUR (Polyurethane): PUR, or polyurethane, is also a thermoset plastic but with a different chemical composition. It is produced by reacting polyols with isocyanates in a 1:1 ratio. The resulting foam is also rigid and closed-cell but is less chemically cross-linked compared to PIR. This difference in the chemical structure impacts the physical properties of the material, particularly its thermal stability and fire resistance.
2. Thermal Insulation Performance
Both PIR and PUR offer excellent thermal insulation properties, which is essential for maintaining the temperature within a walk in cold room. However, PIR panels generally provide better thermal performance compared to PUR panels.
PIR Panels: PIR foam has a lower thermal conductivity, usually around 0.022 to 0.026 W/mK. This means that PIR panels can provide the same level of insulation as PUR panels with a thinner profile, or they can deliver better insulation with the same thickness.
PUR Panels: PUR foam typically has a slightly higher thermal conductivity, ranging from 0.023 to 0.028 W/mK. While still offering good insulation, PUR panels might require a slightly thicker layer to achieve the same thermal resistance as PIR panels.
3. Fire Resistance
One of the most significant differences between PIR and PUR panels lies in their behaviour under fire conditions.
PIR Panels: PIR foam is more fire-resistant due to its chemical structure. It forms a protective char layer when exposed to fire, which helps to slow down the spread of flames. PIR panels are classified as B-s1,d0 under the European fire classification system (EN 13501-1), meaning they have limited combustibility, produce minimal smoke, and do not form flaming droplets.
PUR Panels: PUR foam, on the other hand, is more flammable and does not char as effectively as PIR when exposed to fire. This can result in a faster spread of flames. PUR panels are usually classified as B-s3,d0, indicating they have a higher combustibility, produce more smoke, and may form flaming droplets.
4. Moisture Resistance
Both PIR and PUR panels are resistant to moisture due to their closed-cell structure, which prevents water absorption. However, PIR panels generally exhibit better long-term moisture resistance, maintaining their insulation properties even in high humidity environments. This makes PIR panels particularly suitable for walk-in cold rooms where moisture control is critical.
5. Cost Considerations
PIR Panels: Due to their superior thermal performance and fire resistance, PIR panels are generally more expensive than PUR panels. However, the higher initial cost can be offset by long-term energy savings and enhanced safety features.
PUR Panels: PUR panels are more cost-effective initially, making them a popular choice for projects with tight budgets. However, the lower fire resistance and slightly reduced thermal performance may lead to higher operational costs over time.
6. Applications
PIR Panels: Given their excellent fire resistance and superior thermal insulation, PIR panels are often used in environments with strict fire safety regulations, such as in food processing facilities, pharmaceutical storage, and other high-risk areas.
PUR Panels: PUR panels are commonly used in applications where fire resistance is less of a concern, such as in smaller cold rooms, agricultural storage, or projects where cost is the primary consideration.
7. Environmental Impact
Both PIR and PUR panels are made from petrochemicals, but PIR panels generally have a lower environmental impact due to their higher efficiency, which can reduce energy consumption in cold rooms. Additionally, PIR’s longer lifespan can mean less frequent replacement, leading to a lower environmental footprint over time.
Conclusion
When choosing between PIR and PUR cold room panels, it’s important to consider the specific needs of your project. PIR panels offer superior fire resistance, better thermal performance, and higher moisture resistance, making them ideal for high-risk and energy-efficient applications. PUR panels, while slightly less performant, are more cost-effective upfront and can be a suitable choice for less demanding environments. By understanding these differences, you can make an informed decision that balances safety, efficiency, and cost.
Call us Now on 01283 330 084
or click below for a quote